Sunday, September 14, 2008

Lehman Monday

Now that it looks as if the US government has not bailed out LEH and drawn the line in sand at Fannie & Freddie, let's see if and how the stock market bottoms this time....

The US government finally did the right thing as the list is going to get longer and longer and start involving non financials as well (GM, Ford?). Fannie & Freddie were government already but Bear was the real mistake as that set an artifical bottom in March and allowed market participants to believe that the government would step in (thus creating a premium in the stock market).

Historic Monday (and week) on Wall Street coming up:

1) Lehman gone via bankruptcy (kudos to David Einhorn for calling Lehman out months ago when the stock was at $40)

2) Merrill gone via a takeover by Bank of America: I am shocked that BAC is paying a huge premium ($29) to MER's 17 closing price on Friday. I think that BAC is making a big blunder. If they wanted MER, they should have at least waited until later this week, in case MER traded to single digits. Then they could have offered peanuts. BAC is the same company that bought a hug stake in Countrywide at $18 and watched it go to single digits before paying $8 for the rest of the company. If they had waited, they probably could have got it for $1 or less.

The details are sketchy as I write this: BAC (closed near $34) and deal is supposed to $29 for MER. That would be a 0.85 ratio. I predict that BAC will open near $30 on this news and analysts and shareholders will blast BAC for this. Assuming BAC opens at $30, that would give MER a theoretical price of $25.50 and with the risk inherent in this deal, I would expect MER to probably trade near $22.

3) AIG, a Dow stock, is announcing details of assets sales and asking the Fed for $40 billion in a bridge loan.

4) Washington Mutual is also near bankruptcy or could be sold for next to nothing.

5) Fed meeting on Tuesday. Prior to Sunday, the market only had a 10% chance of a 25 basis pt cut. As I write this, there is now a 60% chance despite all the hawkish rhetoric of Bernanke & Co. Even if the Fed doesn't move on Tuesday, it can move at any time, and an interest rate cut is definitely back on the table, especially if the stock market tanks this week. There are a few hawks on the Fed, but there are also a bunch of academic doves who panic anytime the market goes down a few percent.

Even if we get a panic bottom on Monday, I doubt that it will hold for long, as the world economy is slowing down big time, the financial system is a mess and stocks (and many asset classes) remain overvalued.

Oh yeah, since this is a Canadian site, everything will be fine here, no impact. Housing will continue to go up 5% a year every year and the Canadian economy will be just fine forever...

Full Disclosure: Puts on AIG, MER , SKF and equity in SKF, SDS, QID.

My MER puts are likely to go down versus Friday thanks to BAC's stupidity but they are January paper (bought when MER was in the mid 20s) and I'm not sure that the deal will stick, so I'll have to see what happens tomorrow...



Saturday, September 13, 2008

CREA preannounces....

Funny how this slipped out Friday from the G&M "Cooling Vancouver leads fall in house price"

National sales numbers for August, to be released by the Canadian Real EstateAssociation (CREA) on Monday, will disclose the third consecutive monthly drop in existing-home prices and the largest decline since prices slipped in June for the first time in more than nine years.

Nationwide, the price of a resale home fell more sharply in August than the 2.4 per cent year-over-year drop posted the month before, mainly because of softness in Vancouver, the country's most expensive residential real estate market, said CREA chief economist Gregory Klump.

Sales activity fell by 53.4 per cent in greater Vancouver in August, compared with the year before, and average prices there dropped by 4 per cent for both detached homes and condo units, to $737,985 and $374,366, respectively.

In July, overall housing sales in Vancouver dropped by 44 per cent, while the average price declined by 1 per cent.

Hmmm, prices fell by 4% YoY in Vancouver in August (vs 1% in July). Since Vancouver has the highest prices in Canada, this will drag the overall number down for August.

And CREA will likely spin away 1) saying that the market is now balanced and a great time to buy, 2) the number is skewed by Alberta and BC and 3) this is just a healthy correction and that Canada is nothing like the US.

To which I will say 1) the market is beginning to become more balanced after being a sellers' market for about 7 years. Hence, we need a buyers' market for a number of years to return prices to reasonable levels (i.e. not a few months of "balance" after the biggest bull market in history)

2) Yes, Alberta and BC are dragging things down just as they brought things up in 2006/07. I expect their markets to eventually drop more than others but their crash has only begun. Wait until the foreclosures get started...

3) This is not a healthy correction and Canada is exactly like the US except with a one year lag and overprime instead of subprime

Also, notice how CREA has not updated their 5% figure for 2008. Why should we believe CREA since they have yet to admit we have a problem? The US real estate associaton did the same thing back in 2006 & 2007.

As I said before, once this storm that started in the US in 2005/06, washed up in Alberta late last year and has now spread to BC really hits the center of the universe (Toronto), it is game over for the Canadian housing market.

Plus, what has happened in recent months (and likely with only limited impact in August)?

1) The awful July employment numbers: That is likely to impact housing this fall
2) Commodity and TSX crash/correction since July: Going to make things even worse out west...
3) Credit spread widening making mortgages more expensive and harder to get
4) Fannie & Freddie, Lehman, WaMu only makes 3) worse
5) October 15th mortgage changes AND

what may happen in coming months:

6) Another huge leg down in the overall stock market

Based on the preannouncement from CREA, I now expect August to be at least -5% for the country overall. My projection of -6% to -9% by December is looking more likely and perhaps skewed to the low side of that projection. When I started this blog, I had a question mark on the title. Perhaps I can finally remove that question mark....

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Government Bottoms and Bailouts

All climactic US stock market bottoms have involved government intervention thus far:

Aug 16/07: Fed cuts
discount rate, telegraphs rate cuts (follows up with 50 basis pts in Sept)

Jan 22/08: Socgen bottom: Fed cuts emergency 75 & telegraphs more (another 50 next week)
S&P 1270

Mar 17//08:
Bear Stearns bailout bottom/new lending facilities S&P 1256
July 15/08: Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac announcement of future bailout
S&P 1200
Sep 8/08: Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac takeover S&P 1217 (Friday before)

Every major bottom has been in the 1200-1270 range and every rally has ultimately failed (we are still waiting for July and Sept bottoms to be breached however).

This tells me that market is not bottoming naturally (ie prices low/sellers exhausted/buyers bargain hunting). Perhaps one of the signs that a new bull will be here is when the market bottoms naturally.

What happens on the next Bailout Monday, this week (September 15th)? Washington Mutual (WaMu) and Lehman?

Since the Bear Stearns bailout (with the incessant bottom calling...a financial failed, market bottom- that is so 1998) I have been waiting for a period where more than one bank/broker goes under in the same week and then you get some type of climactic bottom that leads to a multi-month bear market rally (similar to September 2001-January 2002).

We had Fannie & Freddie last weekend and it looks like WaMu and Lehman won't make it much longer. That would be 4 in 1/2 weeks. Weirdly, that would qualify but I don't think these 4 will cut it. It may take a few more bankruptcies or bailouts plus weakness in other sectors (retail? as commodities have already crashed) to cause that type of washout.

Here is my list of candidates once LEH and WaMu are done. I have no special insight, just the way that they are trading:


Bear Stearns

Fannie

Freddie


Very Likely and soon?

Lehman

WaMu

National City

MBIA

Ambac

Wachovia

AIG


Eventually? Some type of takeunder/breakup?

Merrill

Citigroup

Morgan Stanley


Full Disclosure: Puts on MER, C, AIG, MBI, SKF and SKF equity




Saturday, September 6, 2008

Dow 9,000 as President Obama wins election?

On the hottest day of the Montreal summer (33C on Sept 6th!), I felt a need to update my financial markets "winter outlook" from August 8th:

Markets remain choppy for August into mid September 2nd. Commodities bounce a little mid/late August and sell off again in early September. US and world markets peak in mid August, pull back in late August, rally into mid September 2nd to test August highs.

Then we plunge into mid November as the credit crunch really takes hold, the US economy plunges and recession is accepted by all. There is a chance that we get a slew of bank failures at the same time and systemic risk becomes a concern.

Canadian, US and European economies in recession or hard landings. I plan on conserving capital and shorting at opportune times.

Basically, the only change is that the markets topped out faster (Tuesday Sept 2nd) and from a slightly lower level than I thought. Thursday was the first 90% downday (technical measure). If a new downleg has started, you will likely get a series of them over the next few weeks/months.

Cash is king here for all but experienced investors (who can short carefully). Stay out of debt. I saw (and still see) a move to about S&P 1078-1090 (Dow 9Kish?) for this downleg which should last into November, around the time that Barack Obama (or John McCain) becomes the new President.

Some may feel that I am a permabear but I believe that I am a realist. The structural issues facing the global economy are deep. The credit cycle has gone on for most of my life (about 25 years- since the early 80s). Look at any long term chart of debt/GDP, debt/annual income, etc... It will take a severe bear market and a severe and lasting recession to correct the excesses of 25 years. This stock market bear thus far has not been severe (20% +/- on the S&P, 10 months in duration). Severe bear markets can last years (the 2000-03 one lasted about 3 years) and usually shave off 30-50%.

We currently have the worst housing recession in the US and many countries since the Great Depression. We have one the worst financial instability since the Great Depression, as the esteemed Paul Volcker stated today. The US consumer (70% of the US economy and 20% of the world economy) is overleveraged and underwater in his/her stocks and houses. Inflation has been high in recent years, thereby preventing further rate cuts in most countries.

All this and we are supposed to have a garden variety bear market of 20% and 10 months? And Canada is supposed to muddle along impervious to the massive hurt going on to our south. Housing will just magically rise by 5% a year.

I believe that we are likely heading for one of the 50% bear markets in the stock market. We haven't even had a real panic. The August 07 panic was minor. Socgen January was minor. Bear Stearns March bottom was minor. July Fannie Mae bottom was minor. Look at the VIX index. It peaked in the upper 30s in all but the July bottom (it only hit 30 in July). In 1997, 1998, 2000-03, we had numbers in the 50s and 60s. In 1987, we hit 180ish I believe. Perhaps there are structural difference in the markets (ultrashort ETFs, etc...) that will prevent a 60 reading, but even using other measures, we have yet to see true panic in the markets yet. I am old enough to remember scarier "corrections" in the 1997 and 1998 bull markets. There were none of the structural issues out there today! I believe that over the next few weeks you will finally get some panic.

The good news is that after this downleg, I believe that we will finally be past the halfway mark in terms of percentage and maybe, just maybe, in time. We even could get a nice 3 to 5 month counter trend bear market rally. If things got really ugly in October/November and we sunk to say 770 S&P with a few bank failures, you could even have the end to the bear in terms of price.

Eventually, there will be a new secular bull market in stocks and homes. It will probably not be like the ones of the 80s and 90s in stocks and 2000s in homes, but it should be good. We will definitely get a cyclical bull (2003-2007) at some point in 2009 or 2010. The BRIC country story may well be true and if the US can do a (much) bigger 1995-97 Canadian style cleanup cleanup of its structural problems, this could eventually make me start a bullish blog. But the "summer outlook" is likely many years away and for now winter has resumed in the financial markets.

Friday, September 5, 2008

Comments on the G&M website

From the G&M comments

FSA LDU from Canada writes:

Adil, a link to your own blog, spouting about the housing downturn is hardly concrete evidence of the same. I think I'll take the analysis of CREA, the BoC and several major economists over the 'dabbling in financial markets' of a renter.

I dabble in the financial markets too, every time I put my ATM card in a bank machine and take out 20 bucks for lunch and a train ticket home. That gives me as much credence to predict the future of housing prices as you.

As for the job market - great to see our economy still moving forward, albeit slowly, despite the global turmoil in the financials, commodities and jobs. Here's Harper gets his majority and we can enjoy four more years of smart economic planning by our federal government, as opposed to four years of economic hell if the Green Shift ever happens.
I thought I would address his many comments:

Go ahead and trust the CREA, BoC and Big Bank analysts! I think they'll lose you money but that's why we have markets. Notice that I didn't say "free" markets, as the manipulation by the US government with all its new facilities, Bear Stearns bailout, Fed cuts and short selling rule changes have discredited that idea.

As for my credentials, I am comfortable that they are sound enough to work for CREA, BoC etc.., I have a professional designation, many years of experience with financial institutions and I have been a markets junkie for 17 years. I am a renter by choice as I believe that housing is overpriced and I will buy when prices are lower, much lower.

I "dabble" in that I am not a full-time trader and I have a day job as a freelance consultant, but I manage my own portfolio and I am up in the bear market.

The gist of FSA LDU's comments are that I am not credible because I don't work for a big institution. That's fine by me. I'll let you the reader be the judge of that, but I have made many predictions on this blog and most of them seem to be coming to fruition. I do plan to change the profile description (thanks to FSA) as it does sound a little hokey.

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

A 1 year lag

CREA likes to say: “"The Canadian real estate market, while cooling, is still much different than the U.S. market”

Actually, it really isn’t…

Using CREA data in a crude way, it appears that as of June 2008, we are lagging the US by about 1 year and 2 months. This is consistent with the lag of June 2007. In late 2007/early 2008, we were lagging by a little more (1.5 years) due perhaps to the effect of the commodity bubble on the West.

In July 2008, the lag appears to have shrunk once again to 1 year and 2 months as some of the effect of the commodity bubble appears to be coming out of the Alberta market.

I know that this is not apples to apples, since CREA reports average sales price and Case/Schiller reports a number based on the “repeat sales pricing technique”

However, here goes. If we continue to lag the US by about 1 year and 3 months (I have added a month, in case July was a bit of an extreme), this is where we go for the next year or so.

Back of Envelope Calculations

Canadian Date CREA YoY US Similar Date (Case/Schiller) Lag
Jun-07 10.40% Apr-06 1 year, 2 months
Dec-07 8.10% Jun-06 1 year, 6 months
Mar-08 4.00% Sep-06 1 year, 6 months
Jun-08 0.40% Jan-07 1 year, 5 months
Jul-08 -3.60% May-07 1 year, 2 months
Sep-08 -3.90%? Jun-07 1 year, 3 months
Dec-08 -5.50%? Sep-07 1 year, 3 months
Mar-09 -9.70%? Dec-07 1 year, 3 months
Jun-09 -15.30%? Mar-08 1 year, 3 months


This is not a prediction but merely something to watch. However, for the remaining months of 2008, this is probably a decent estimate of where we go. In fact, it could be conservative if the following effects hit the Canadian housing market this fall:

TSX has a sharp selloff this fall (as I expect)
Commodity prices are now in a bear market (as I expect)
Banks will tighten lending this fall, especially once the October 15th deadline passes
Psychology will change as the “boom is over” become accepted by the masses

I suspect that we go to -6% YoY conservatively by December 2008 and perhaps as low as -9% YoY. For 2009, I don’t know about -15.3% by June 2009 as that will depend on how things play out in the economy and financial markets. I wouldn’t rule it out however!

Friday, August 15, 2008

Down 3.6% in July

"The question is no longer will Canadian house prices drop but whether they will sink to levels seen in the United States where some markets have watched home prices crumble by as much as 30% in the last year."
Financial Post, Gary Marr, August 15, 2008. "Alberta leads national drop in home prices"

Well said...Only problem is just a few months ago, we were hearing tales of a slowdown to 5% growth in 2008 (from 11% in 2007). This is the first time that the FP or G&M (to my recollection) has stated unequivocally that Canadian housing prices will fall. The mainstream media just keeps repeating the doggie do-do that the CREA/real estate people and the banks keep spouting.

July 2008: The average sales price declined 3.6% YoY. As bearish as I am on housing, even I didn't expect that bad a number!

CREA is trying to spin away:

In June, it was only 4 of 25 markets going negative (Calgary and Edmonton included) going negative. The number was skewed....

In July, now you can add Vancouver to the list. Toronto is quite close now at 1.5%. Windsor is now negative.

Listen to CREA spin furiously :
" Even though average prices continue to post year-over-year gains in most major markets...the decline was the result of fewer sales compared to a year ago in the four most expensive major markets in Canada – Vancouver, Victoria, Calgary and Toronto."

Hmm, the four most expensive major markets in Canada had fewer sales. Yes, mathematically that would skew the average price downward as you lose more higher prices sales in your mix.

BUT...Is it not concerning to see the #1 and #3 cities (Tor/Van) have fewer sales and go negative in inflation adjusted (real) terms. The other 3 rich cities in Canada (Calgary, Edmonton, Victoria) go negative and/or fewer sales.

How many major cities are there in Canada not affected by this housing crash developing.

Let's start from West to East with all cities over 1 million:

1) Vancouver: From BMO "However, the drop in July spread to a few more cities, including the previously untouchable Vancouver market."
Vancouver is the Michael Jordan of housing markets. Sales down 44%!!
2) Calgary: Negative (big time)
3) Edmonton: Negative (big time)
4) Toronto: slowly sales/barely up (1.5%)
5) Ottawa: holding up so far
6) Montreal:
holding up so far (new high in average price)

I don't know about Ottawa, but I live in Montreal. Everything happens with a lag here. We've been spared some of the worst recently with some provincial income tax cuts and a strong aerospace sector. Plus, culturally we are a little insulated from what goes on in the ROC, but it gets here eventually.

I would expect to see all 6 major Canadian cities negative YoY by year end. I would expect to see Calgary, Edmonton, Vancouver and Toronto all negative by October latest.


What are the hot areas in terms of price increases?

Saskatchewan and Newfoundland/Labrador (ie commodity bubble land). With the upcoming commodity implosion and housing bubbles in those areas, look for them to follow Calgary and Edmonton's lead. Saskatchewan is already having huge drops in sales volume and anecdotal reports report that much of the increase was due to investment buying, much of it from Alberta. Potash stock price is a good proxy for Saskatchewan's economy. I don't have a position in Potash currently but I have shorted it recently and I think it is reminiscent of JDSU back in 2000.


One last spin by CREA's economists:
"Based on what happened in the first half of the year, CREA’s market analysis shows a record national average residential MLS® price by the end of 2008, but with a much more modest increase than was recorded in 2007."

Translation: instead of 5% growth for 2008 (down from 11% in 2007), we are now projecting to go to get back to postive (ie +0.1%) by December.

My take:

  • Expect to see negative numbers the rest of the year
  • Expect Toronto to go negative soon. When the mainstream media (based primarily in Toronto) gets this, expect to see a flood of housing doom articles. While the doom will be correct, it will be about years late.
  • Expect Ottawa and Montreal to participate in the housing crash by year end
  • Expect to see negative numbers worsen with an occasional upward blip (similar to a bear market rally in the stock market- ie nothing goes down in a straight line)
  • Expect to see bottom calling on these inevitable blips
  • Expect to see a negative 6-9% by year end