We got confirmation that the turn is here with the April numbers. April was a uneventful month weatherwise in most of the country, so the bulls couldn't use the snow as an excuse (except maybe in Alberta?).
I asked recently whether CREA was just making up bullish fantasy numbers as they almost ignored the huge drop off in the housing market when they revised their 2008 projections downward. They did drop their estimate of housing sales but they barely touched the all-important sales price increase (5.5% to 5.3%). I figured that since they wrote it on May 6th, they must have had at least some clue on the April numbers: Since March was up only 4% YoY, they must have seen at least some stabilization in the sales price increase to justify going with a 5.3% figure for the full year. I was thinking maybe a small uptick to 5% YoY in April...
Wrong! According to CREA's numbers, April saw a YoY increase of only 3.2%. The only good news for housing bulls was that the sales drop was only 6.1% (versus an 18% drop in March). New listings soared by 18%.
For sales to average an increase of 5.3%, we would have to get some 5-6% figures in the second half. That would require not only immediate stabilization in pricing but a pickup in price. With new listings picking up, people spending a fortune on gas and the economy slowing, good luck with that.
Let's see what May brings but I think a negative number is likely before the leaves turn this fall...
Wednesday, May 14, 2008
Another Bad Month!
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
TSX hits a new high but vulnerable
I mentioned last month that the TSX was just a good day away from a new high. It took a little bit longer than a day but we finally got there on Monday. Oil and a select group of commodities hit new highs. Most commodities still remain below their Feb/March highs. The TSX also leveraged a strong bear market rally in the US (or a new bull market rally, only time will tell).
Gold has had a nice selloff here, but oil seems to me to be in either a huge speculative blow off phase or in a "peak oil" new paradigm. Once again, only time will tell.
I will repeat what I said last month:
"bubbles can persist for a long time, and perhaps I am way too early on this one.
What will be the catalyst?
One thing that can hurt commodities in the short run is a strong US dollar. The US dollar has become universally despised. If it can put a short/intermediate term bottom here versus the Euro and rally to 1.50-1.52, it could put a top in oil, gold and other commodities..."
Since I wrote that on April 21, the USD has rallied versus the Euro to 1.54 and a short/intermediate top has been put in for gold, silver and many other commodities. Oil has remained immune.
It bears repeating again: Just recognize that the TSX is not a very diversified index. 75% of the TSX in 3 groups (mining, oils and financials). There are 3 mega cap stocks in Toronto (Encana, Potash and Research in Motion). We all remember what happened to the TSX (TSE back then) in the Nortel crash. This could be similar...
I believe that US financials are going to get uglier in 2008, and commodities are in some type of bubblish top here. Doing some back of the envelope calculations (assuming that the US is in recession and still in a bear market):
- Say we get a 20% correction from record levels in energy and material stocks and a 10% hit to financials (near the March lows) and we keep everything else (including RIM) flat, that would translate into a 12,800 TSX (about 13% off current levels).
- Say we get a 30% hit to energy/materials and 20% hit to the financials everything else, that would be an 11,000 TSX (25% off)
These are not outlandish scenarios in my book. If we get a typical 30% bear in the US and the commodity bubble bursts, I would expect the TSX to at least test the 11,000 level.
Keep these things in mind as we hit a new record...
Long SKF, HXD, QID
Tuesday, May 6, 2008
Are they just making this stuff up?
Is CREA just making this stuff up? Earlier in the year, they projected existing home sales to drop by only 1.6%. After some horrible March data, I mentioned that their numbers were fantasy.
Well, it appears that they agree. Today they chopped their numbers down big time.
From the CREA website:
National home sales are forecast to ease 11.5 per cent to 460,900 units in 2008,
and to ease a further four per cent the following year.
They increased their estimate of the sales drop from 1.6% to 11.5%. I think that when it is all said and done, 11.5% will seem low (there was a 13% drop in Q1 alone). But, OK, fine.
What about price? They had previously projected a price increase of 5.5%.
CREA says:
The MLS® residential average price is forecast to rise 5.3 per cent in 2008 and a
further 4.2 per cent next year, pushing prices to new heights.
So they did a decent cut to their sales numbers but barely touched the average price forecast! There will be approximately 50K less homes sold this year and perhaps 50K of extra inventory (than they forecasted just 3 months ago). They think that losing those 50K transactions will have no impact on selling prices and that home prices will still increase by a magical 5%. I see....
Since the average price increased by just 4% in March, they are basically saying that the huge slowdown in the housing market this winter will magically stabilize here. Even if you allow for the possibility that the February and March numbers were snow related, you would need to get a decent April number (ie 5%ish) to justify 5% for the full year. Since it is May 6th, I would imagine that CREA already has a reasonably accurate preliminary figure for April. Therefore, I would not be surprised to see a decent April number. This would do little to change the chain of events that I listed last month.
Thursday, May 1, 2008
Now, can we ask the question again?
I asked the question back in February: Did we go into recession in December?
I am still waiting for the G&M or Financial Post to ask this question.
Today we got news that February GDP was -0.2%. On April 1st, I stated that based on Dec-Jan data, it appears that the economy was basically going flat. So now we can make it 3 months of basically no growth.
Can we at least start to ask the question, and also ask: If we are at zero now, and then the housing bubble and commodity bubble only began to deflate in March, how do we avoid recession?
G&M? FP?
Tuesday, April 29, 2008
The Canadian consumer is extremely healthy
Banks bank on ‘healthy' Canadian consumer,
“The Canadian consumer is extremely healthy right now,” Dave McKay, the new head of domestic banking at Royal Bank of Canada, said at a presentation for analysts in Toronto.
“The Canadian consumer is strong, they have not leveraged the equity in their homes nearly to the extent the U.S. has, so there is still opportunity there,” he said, noting the need to be prudent.
But “I do not lose any sleep at night about our home equity business whatsoever,” Mr. McKay said, noting that “you can't compare the Canadian and U.S. home equity market, they're just night and day.”
Yet another sign of a top?
This dude Dave has really drunk the Kool-aid or more likely, he is talking up his company. He is saying that people can even take out more money from this homes (since they didn't get as crazy as the Americans) and that he is sleeping well at night.
Does he not see the turn in the Canadian housing market? The other housing markets in the world that are falling? The commodity bubble that seems to be starting to implode again as the US dollar strengthens? Nope, he points to record employment and the fact that Canadian banks keep their mortgages on their books as reasons that things will not fall apart here.
I believe that the job market has turned in recent months and that things are really slowing down in Montreal and Toronto based on my limited contacts. I'm not hearing about layoffs yet, but this is to simply point out that if the housing and commodity markets head south, the job market will follow. Housing lead the job market in the US and I believe a similar thing is happening worldwide.
As for keeping mortgages on the books: I will need to research this, but my gut feeling is that the banks were giving money away in many cases. In a boom, banks make money by lending to anyone. In a crunch, they stop lending to almost everyone.
Even Mr RBC Bull points out an alarming point (for a bull):
There has been a shift toward lengthy mortgage terms of 40 years. Mr. McKay said it's something RBC has been warning customers about. Bank staff tell customers their interest and carrying costs will go up with lengthier mortgages, and make them aware of the pitfalls and costs, he said. Customers are responding by saying “I understand that,” but they want to free up their cash flow in the shorter-term, and plan to pay off their mortgage in fewer than 40 years by making lump sum payments, he said. “Customers have consistently told us that they plan on managing it,” he said. “Whether they can all do it or not is a good question.”
Of course customers plan on managing it. They assume that the good times will always be here and that they will always have a job, no need for any savings and they will make a lot more money in the future. Plus, their house will appreciate 20% per year....
Conclusion: I don't buy it. The Canadian consumer is doing OK for now because of the huge windfall from the commodity and housing bubbles and a soaring Canadian dollar (that has lowered core inflation). If those one-time factors are finished for at least the time being and the credit crunch really rears its ugly head, our Canadian consumer will be headed to the doctor.
Monday, April 21, 2008
Commodity Markets Updated
It appears that I was a little early in my bearish call on commodities. However, with the exception of oil and a few select commodities, most are still below their Feb/March highs. I covered most of my shorts at small losses in late March when it looked as if the Socgen and Bear Stearns lows would hold. I played gold pretty well thus far as I took profits on some big down days.
I still think that commodities (excluding gold) are headed lower this year and the TSX with it. The TSX is actually a big up day away from its all-time highs! (With the exception of HGD (an ultrashort gold ETF), I have no positions here but may take some in the future).
Bubbles can persist for a long time, and perhaps I am way too early on this one.
What will be the catalyst?
One thing that can hurt commodities in the short run is a strong US dollar. The US dollar has become universally despised. If it can put a short/intermediate term bottom here versus the Euro and rally to 1.50-1.52, it could put a top in oil, gold and other commodities, especially given the leverage and profits inherent in these positions. The Fed meeting next week looks like a 25 pt cut, and this could be the spark that the USD needs.
What are some of the clues that perhaps this commodity rally is not for real?
1) The Canadian dollar topped in November at 1.10. It is currently near par. It has not confirmed the 2008 commodity rally (bearish divergence). If commodity prices were to continue strong, shouldn't the Canadian dollar be stronger? Perhaps the loonie has been weak due to the aggressive rate cuts or perhaps it was simply too speculative a move back in November.
2) Record oil prices have only recently allowed oil stocks to hit new highs. Perhaps this is due to general stock market weakness or perhaps the stocks are leading the underlying commodity... The same is true in certain other areas (such as gold). I believe that the crude oil market is not a free market with a level playing field as it trades so strangely. However, if we get a true breakdown (as we did in Sept 2006) to sub $100, this would likely bring the rest of the commodities down as well. I don't buy the BRIC argument and I think that oil at these levels can not be explained by demand pressures.
Since it also looks as if the financial rally is ending, the 75% of the TSX in 3 groups (mining, oils and financials) could be vulnerable here. I don't think most Canadians realize how risky the TSX is right here.
I'm also looking for the BoC to cut 50 tommorrow.
Thursday, April 17, 2008
I was wrong: The Turn is Here
WOW!! The March data from CREA was off the charts horrible...
I was wrong when I wrote this on April 8:
" Canada's turn may be coming. Clearly, the turn in Canada is not here as of March 2008. However, this does not mean that the turn isn't coming."
The snowy February numbers were not good, but they were not disastrous (a la Britain's March). I thought that March would show some deterioration over the Feb numbers, but not to this level. I wrote that line attempting to take the focus away from a myopic short term view and look to the future. Well, the future is here...
The average selling price of existing homes in March rose by only 4% YoY (down huge from 6.2% YoY in February and 11% for 2007). YoY sales number for March dropped almost 19%!!
That is a huge slowdown that has brought price increases down near to the CPI rate. This means that a house is showing almost no appreciation in real terms.
CREA had projected a national 2008 price increase of 5.5% and a slight decrease in sales to 512K (from 520K in 2007, a drop of 1.6%). Those numbers are fantasy now based on the Feb & March data.
Here is a summary of the CREA numbers (gathered from press release, articles):
| 2008 Proj | 2008 Q1 | Feb 08 | Mar 08 | |
| Proj | Act | Act | Act | |
| YoY | YoY | YoY | YoY | |
| Price | 5.5% | 5.5% | 6.2% | 4.0% |
| Sales | -1.5% | -13.0% | -10.0% | -18.7% |
In the G&M today:
“Canada's six-year housing market boom is officially over. Aside from a few choice prairie locales, sales are melting faster than this year's snowpack,” Douglas Porter, deputy chief economist at BMO Nesbitt Burns, said in a research note.
New listings (inventory) were up huge as well. March sales fell by 40% in Calgary, 34% in Edmonton and 22% in Toronto
In the G&M, it points out that Porter and TD continue to expect "moderate home-price gains" for the year. Do they really believe this or are they speaking for their bosses who hope to avoid a US style crash? Ted Carmichael of JPMorgan talks about price declines in the next 12 to 18 months in the National Post. JPM has a smaller presence in Canada, so maybe he is more free to speak his mind?
The turn is here. The chain of events that I put out last week may need revision, but I'll wait until we get further confirmation with the April numbers, as it is dangerous to rely too much on one data point.
I am not 100% sure about this (I will need to research further) but it appears that the British and Canadian housing markets are turning faster than the US market did in 2005/06. Moderate home price gains are optimistic and would require a immediate stabilization at March levels. The employment picture has slowed down big-time in recent weeks, the credit crunch effects are only beginning to be felt and the inventory has only started to build.
I will venture a guesstimate that the national home price "increase" will be close to zero sometime this summer. And maybe then the CREA will blame the heat...